There’s a lot of factors that go into what attracts a viewer to a movie. It could be the visuals, it could be the premise and the cast. Sometimes within the cast it’s just a single person that makes people want to see it. For this particular movie it seems at the time of its release, the main attraction to this feature was Cher. Although she was not unknown at the time and had been in several productions before, she still hadn’t headlined too many movies. And being that Cher has been looked up to by so many for her ambitions and beauty, seeing her name and the title of the movie looks like it would be some kind of a unique fantasy any young girl would look at, thinking it would be for them. Cher and mermaids sound like they would go hand in hand.
The premise for this film is about Mrs. Flax (Cher) and her two daughters Charlotte (Winona Ryder) and Kate (Christine Ricci) finding a town they can call their home. The problem is, Mrs. Flax is not one to stay too long for commitment reasons. That it is until she meets Lou Landsky (Bob Hoskins) who happens to show Mrs. Flax that he’s not like other men she has met. Meanwhile Charlotte is trying to find love among strangers and wants to be a good daughter. The original story came from a novel by Patty Dann of which this is her only work that’s been adapted to film. Adapting this novel was done by June Roberts who had only wrote for one film almost a decade before. Directing this feature came under Richard Benjamin, a veteran of the classic Hollywood era who acted in Westworld (1973) and even directed other films like City Heat (1984).
When it comes to the plot, the execution makes sense. However, if one is expecting some type of fantasy element revolving around mermaids, viewers will be sadly mistaken. Other than a visual reference to the title during a New Year’s Eve party, nothing else really is said about the title. Maybe the meaning behind it is about how mermaids are eternally single? As they are typically creatures that lure men to their deaths as oppose to the family friendly version presented by Disney. But this is never made clear though, so it can definitely confuse some viewers. Other than that, everything about the story is okay. The characters are written where the viewer can understand their opinions on things. Charlotte wants to be nothing like her mother, who is clever, sassy and attractive for all the wrong reasons.
She also wants to remain celibate before getting married, which her mother thinks is preposterous. The one person Charlotte has her sights set on is Joe (Michael Schoeffling), a simple town guy who everyone respects, likes and works with nuns, mainly mother superior (Jan Miner). The only thing that can get on some viewer’s nerves is that Charlotte is always in her head monologuing, which can be a bit tiresome to hear her thoughts. Cher as Mrs. Flax plays her role almost like one would expect her to play as described before. She is her own woman, ain’t no man is going to tell her what she has to do, and she can get any man she desires. There are a few interactions that she has with Lou and her daughter Charlotte that show how her attitude impacts others. Bob Hoskins plays Lou like the guy who would ground Mrs. Flax, although he does look a little too old for her.
Christina Ricci as the youngest daughter is cute in her own way. This was her first theatrical debut and really seems like she was given permission to do whatever she liked. When it came to the camerawork, Howard Atherton was the designated cinematographer. For this picture much of what shot looks okay, but nothing that stands out either. Atherton would later shoot for Bad Boys (1995) and Deep Rising (1998). Lastly the film score behind the music was composer Jack Nitzsche. Probably best known for his work on One Flew Over the Cuckoo’s Nest (1975) and Starman (1984), the work behind here feels a little underwhelming. The main theme sounds like what could’ve been the start of The Entertainer song but then quickly moves to other notes. There doesn’t seem to be an album available either so maybe it wasn’t a very notable effort on his part.
The story and acting are all fine. It’s just the confusing title along with average camerawork and music that makes this Cher film rather uneventful.
Points Earned --> 5:10